You can't buy happiness, but a few bottles of outstanding Champagne wines in warm company definitely bring you closer to the heavens. Elena Menshikova is our messiah. Her quest to taste all popular Champagne labels is alluring[fn:1]. And thus we, her humble followers, bath in the eternal light of sparkling delight. And for the sake of all that is Holy, do not imagine the previous sentence.

Most wine-tasting events are reminiscent of roller coasters if you look at the ratings. Sometimes, the graph contains several spikes. Sometimes, there is a single lonely peak. But monotonic growth of the average score? That's a rare bird in my book.

Of course, in terms of personal preferences (as opposed to the average score), the real battle was between Cristal Rosé 2012 and Krug Rosé 26ème Édition. It's also nice to see that some participants picked other bottles as their favourite of the night.

Without further ado, meet the protagonists (and antagonists).

Wine	Place	rms	wavg	sdev	fav	out	price	volume	QPR
Brut Réserve NV Taittinger	🏅 8th	3.7761	3.8000	0.0256	0	11	UAH 2,200.00	0.75 L	0.5840 😐
Brut Nature (d2021Q4) NV Billecart Salmon	🏅 7th	3.9560	3.9542	0.0116	0	0	UAH 3,200.00	0.75 L	0.6589 😐
Phéérie 2016 Lamiable	🏅 6th	4.1007	4.0722	0.0055	1	0	UAH 2,200.00	0.75 L	1.0104 😊
Brut Blanc de Noir Parcelle d'Aÿ Meurtet William Deutz 2015 Deutz	🏅 5th	4.2381	4.2250	0.0150	1	0	UAH 4,500.00	0.75 L	0.9695 🤔
Emotion 2012 Vilmart & Cie	🏅 4th	4.4328	4.4035	0.0083	2	0	UAH 5,800.00	0.75 L	0.9963 🤔
Cristal Rosé 2012 Louis Roederer	🥉 3rd	4.6008	4.5750	0.0073	2	0	UAH 35,000.00	0.75 L	0.7341 😐
Rosé 26ème Édition Brut NV Krug	🥈 2nd	4.6562	4.6569	0.0152	5	0	UAH 27,900.00	0.75 L	0.9837 🤔
N.P.U. 1996 Bruno Paillard	🥇 1st	4.7422	4.7035	0.0122	0	0	UAH 15,900.00	0.75 L	1.4439 😊

Taittinger Brut Reserve NV

Region: France » Champagne AOC
Type: white traditional sparkling, brut
Producer: Taittinger
Wine: Brut Réserve
Vintage: NV
Disgorged: N/A
On lees: N/A
Grapes: Pinot Noir, Chardonnay
Alcohol: 12.5
Sugar: 9.8
Volume: 750 mL

This wine secured the 🏅 8th place in our wine tasting lineup.

It's not bad. Aye, it's straightforward, single-layered and ridiculously overpriced. There are plenty of sparkling wines delivering the same quality and pleasure for a much better price.

Anyways. Some pears on the yeasty canvas with notes of white flowers and lemon curd. Quite fresh, round and buttery. The aftertaste is empty. Yes, there is acidity and sweetness, but all the flavours fade quickly.

After reading my own notes, I am puzzled by such a high score.

Billecart Salmon Brut Nature (d2021Q4) NV

Region: France » Champagne AOC
Type: white traditional sparkling, brut nature
Producer: Billecart Salmon
Wine: Brut Nature (d2021Q4)
Vintage: NV, based on 2016
Disgorged: 2021Q4
On lees: ~55 months
Grapes: Chardonnay, Pinot Noir, Pinot Meunier
Alcohol: 12
Volume: 750 mL

This wine secured the 🏅 7th place in our wine tasting lineup.

Thanks to Anton T, I discovered that loads of information about each Billecart-Salmon wine is accessible by the 6-digit number printed on the counter label. It's not unique, so here is the link to the bottle we tasted.

For the lazy people and for the sake of the "completeness" of this site, I decided to steal a small portion of the information.

Brut Nature is a blend of Pinot Noir (28%), Chardonnay (28%) and Pinot Meunier (44%), sourced from 40 crus scattered around the Champagne region. This specific bottle consists of 36% base wines from the harvest of 2016. Everything else is reserve wines spanning to 2006. The majority of wine (96%) is vinified in stainless steel tanks. MLF is partial.

0 dosage. Disgorged in the 4th quarter of 2021 (hence the identifier on this site).

Quite delicate (or even restrained) bouquet of a single and (lonely) mushroom, baked apples, buttered croissant, tarragon and candied lemon. The wine offers a nice combination of fruits and ageing hints. Fresh, tense and delicious. It's relatively complex with a long and delicate aftertaste.

Lamiable Phéérie 2016

Region: France » Champagne AOC
Type: white traditional sparkling, extra brut
Producer: Lamiable
Wine: Phéérie
Vintage: 2016
Disgorged: 2022-12
On lees: 68 months
Grapes: Chardonnay
Alcohol: 12.5
Sugar: 2.3
Volume: 750 mL

This wine secured the 🏅 6th place in our wine tasting lineup.

A Champagne house you are unlikely to mention in a list of the most popular producers. Yet we, consumers, should be happy as Phéérie is about value. At least, on the Ukranian market. And it's Grand Cru (Tours sur Mame)!

A wine that doesn't steal your attention, but makes everything better. It's great to drink it now; solo or with food; while reading, playing or talking to friends. Not a very expressive bouquet of baked apples, chalk and honey. Hard to extract descriptors, but it's a pleasant and relatively sophisticated wine. A round, salty and delicious palate with a long and flavourful aftertaste - mushrooms and seabreeze.

Deutz Brut Blanc de Noir Parcelle d'Aÿ Meurtet William Deutz 2015

Region: France » Champagne AOC
Type: white traditional sparkling, brut
Producer: Deutz
Wine: Brut Blanc de Noir Parcelle d'Aÿ Meurtet William Deutz
Vintage: 2015
Disgorged: N/A
On lees: N/A
Grapes: Pinot Noir
Alcohol: 12.5
Sugar: 9.6
Volume: 750 mL

This wine secured the 🏅 5th place in our wine tasting lineup.

My Google-fu is reaching the near-zero mark, so all bits of information stopped moving in my direction. From what I could gather, it seems that there are two parcels used for Hommage a William Deutz (one of the house founders) series production - Meurtet (2.42) and Côte Glaciere (1.92 ha). Both are adjacent to the house itself. Blanc de Noir is 100% Pinot Noir from Meurtet. Some sources (no links, cause not trustworthy) say that the wine spent 84 months on lees (fine lees, of course). If you have any extra information to share, don't hesitate to contact me.

The wine offers a delicate bouquet of tarragon, ripe yellow apples, tangerine (or mandarin, but not the language), fresh brioche, crushed apple seeds and a fistful of white flowers. Relatively good acidity, nice volume and length of the aftertaste with flavours of wet cellar. Great to drink. Bubbles are quick to fade, but the wine is vinous and complex.

Vilmart & Cie Emotion 2012

Region: France » Champagne
Type: rose traditional sparkling, brut
Producer: Vilmart & Cie
Wine: Emotion
Vintage: 2012
Disgorged: 2018-05
On lees: 60 months
Grapes: Pinot Noir, Chardonnay
Alcohol: 12.5
Sugar: 8
Volume: 750 mL

This wine secured the 🏅 4th place in our wine tasting lineup.

A 60/40 blend of Saignée Pinot Noir and Chardonnay from 45-year-old vines in Rilly-la-Montagne, vinified in barrels for 10 months without malolactic fermentation.

Emotion was one of those wines I wouldn't mind not being present in the final lineup. On the one hand, we already tasted it a few weeks before. On the other hand, it was kind of spoiled and showed some promise (although I liked it nevertheless). So I was emo-curious, but not too much. If it turns into an outstanding wine, I'll be happy. That's the motto of a person who just loves to drink (wine). The result?

Emotion is an intense, generous, quaffable and sophisticated wine. It bursts with notes of orange oil, grapefruit (Sicilian orange?), strawberries, cream, bruised red apples, mould, smelly seawater and dark bread crust. The aftertaste is almost eternal (I had to make the second sip thus prolonging this already-lasting sensation) with flavours of grapefruit and Jerez. Despite the age, Emotion offers great acidity, which attacks you but with love and care as the palate is well-balanced.

Louis Roederer Cristal Rosé 2012

Region: France » Champagne AOC
Type: rose traditional sparkling, brut
Producer: Louis Roederer
Wine: Cristal Rosé
Vintage: 2012
Disgorged: N/A
On lees: N/A
Grapes: Pinot Noir, Chardonnay
Alcohol: 12
Sugar: 8
Volume: 750 mL

This wine secured the 🥉 3rd place in our wine tasting lineup.

The 2012 Cristal Rosé is a 56/44 blend of Pinot Noir and Chardonnay. No malolactic (not really) fermentation. 15% is vinified in oak casks. The rosé part is created using the 'infusion' method.

With windows wide by my side, I would drink the 2012 Cristal Rosé till the end of this chapter. It is generous as an inexperienced but very enthusiastic person. Tarragon, raw dough, nuts, white flowers, tangerine, peach, raspberry, bergamot and cocoa powder. It takes time and patience to reveal all these features, and I reckon it could be even deeper if I had time to wait. It is complex and multilayered. The aftertaste is evolving and persistent, it creates images of incredible curves (mathematically speaking) in my mind. Young, delicious, inexperienced and charming.

Krug Rosé 26ème Édition Brut NV

Region: France » Champagne AOC
Type: rose traditional sparkling, brut
Producer: Krug
Wine: Rosé 26ème Édition Brut
Vintage: NV, based on 2014
Disgorged: N/A
On lees: N/A
Grapes: Pinot Noir, Chardonnay, Pinot Meunier
Alcohol: 12.5
Volume: 750 mL

This wine secured the 🥈 2nd place in our wine tasting lineup.

The story repeats. Just like Brut 2006, this wine needs time to open up. Frankly speaking, my tasting skills are lacking and I need at least half of the bottle and at least an hour to figure out everything (I can figure out).

Initially, it's restrained but the taste blows me away to the blessed land. With time it reveals notes of orange oil, tarragon, smoke, red berries, red apples, wet wood, caramel and barberry candies. It's so silky that it reminds me of nitrogen-infused beverages. It's delicate, detailed and multilayered. But it's also intense and almost full-bodied. The aftertaste is long, evolving and flavourful. Grapefruit, oil and wet cellar. It's just so great that I want to repeat it.

P.S. This is the only score that I changed (from 4.5 to 4.6).

Bruno Paillard N.P.U. 1996

Region: France » Champagne AOC
Type: white traditional sparkling, extra brut
Producer: Bruno Paillard
Wine: N.P.U.
Vintage: 1996
Disgorged: 2009-01
On lees: 144 months
Grapes: Chardonnay, Pinot Noir
Alcohol: 12
Sugar: 5.1
Volume: 750 mL

This wine secured the 🥇 1st place in our wine tasting lineup.

It's not intended to be the best wine, but a cuvée that we push to the extreme.

[…] liveliness is more the focus here than complexity and richness.

— Alice Paillard

A 50/50 blend of Pinot Noir and Chardonnay from 7 of the most sought-after Grands Crus of the Champagne terroir: Oger, Le Mesnil-sur-Oger, Chouilly, Cramant, Verzenay, Mailly-Champagne, and Bouzy. Grapes are vinified and matured in small, old oak barrels for 10 months. Then the wine spends 12 years on lees followed by two years of post-disgorgement rest before release.

The 1996 Nec Plus Ultra is where the empty space is a saving grace. Aye, it talks in the language of baked cheese, beeswax, boiled eggs (in a very good sense, trust me), miso and tarragon (it follows me everywhere even when I close my eyes shut). But its freshness creates a vacuum that is filled with complexity, elegance and longevity. I was already tired, so maybe next time I would rate it higher. In any case, it's a remarkable wine and the age only makes it better.

Raw scores

Wine	Vitalii M	Roman R	Elena M	Anna Z	Boris B	Anton T	Yurii M	Ivan M	Ekaterina P	Khrystyna S	Vova U
Brut Réserve NV Taittinger	4.00	3.80	3.70	4.00	3.80	3.80	3.50	3.90	3.50	3.70	3.80
Brut Nature (d2021Q4) NV Billecart Salmon	4.10	4.00	3.90	4.10	3.90	3.90	4.00	4.00	3.70	4.00	3.90
Phéérie 2016 Lamiable	4.10	4.10	4.00	4.10	4.00	4.10	4.20	4.20	4.10	4.20	4.00
Brut Blanc de Noir Parcelle d'Aÿ Meurtet William Deutz 2015 Deutz	4.10	4.20	4.20	4.10	4.20	4.30	4.50	4.30	4.10	4.40	4.20
Emotion 2012 Vilmart & Cie	4.50	4.50	4.40	4.50	4.30	4.40	4.30	4.40	4.60	4.50	4.35
Cristal Rosé 2012 Louis Roederer	4.60	4.60	4.60	4.60	4.50	4.60	4.40	4.70	4.70	4.70	4.60
Rosé 26ème Édition Brut NV Krug	4.80	4.70	4.70	4.80	4.60	4.60	4.50	4.60	4.40	4.80	4.70
N.P.U. 1996 Bruno Paillard	4.70	4.80	4.80	4.70	4.50	4.60	4.70	4.90	4.80	4.80	4.85

About

Champagne Party by Elena and Roma Vol. 3